Ulysses vs. Scrivener.

By Khomus, 2 November, 2024

Forum
macOS and Mac Apps

Hi all.

I decided to post in Mac, because that's where I'll primarily be working. But I know both of these apps are accessible on iOS as well, so I'd appreciate anything about that experience as well that might help me make a decision.

I hear good things about both Ulysses and Scrivener. I want to make a project that's a series of blog posts, or possibly an e-book. I know both can do that as well. My thought was to use Scrivener, but Ulysses has a lot of interesting features and I know a friend has used it for academic papers.

My project is going to be about the lyre, specifically the Anglo-Saxon lyre. However, I intend to include examples of modern playing where lyres still exist, mostly from Africa. So here is why I thought to use Scrivener.

Suppose I comment on a specific lyre from Africa. I include a link to playing, talk about tuning, technique, whatever I can dig up on it. later I find something new. Or maybe I'm not sure where it will fit in the text.

As I understand it, Scrivener let's you work in blocks, and this is why I thought to use it. So if I'm talking about the litungu of the Luhya, I can have that as a block of text or notes or whatever. Then as I put it together, I just go,that block, put it next, instead of having it as a separate file, opening it, selecting the text, and pasting it. But maybe you can also do this in Ulysses?

My reasoning is that I can just start work anywhere, e.g. gather info and videos on a specific lyre, instead of writing text and then going, here is where I want to talk about this lyre, pausing and finding stuff on it, writing that, and so on. Of course I could just do this normally, but the way I'd work at least would involve putting information in separate files. So I thought having some way that would be more organized, particularly if I want to work on both Mac and iOS, might be useful.

Scrivener seems like it would do this, because as I understand it, at least one way you can use it is writing things in sections/blocks of text, and then you can rearrange those blocks as chunks of text. I have no idea how Ulysses handles that kind of thing. I'm sure somebody here does though. So I'd be interested in people's thoughts, particularly if you've used both programs.

Options

Comments

By Ollie on Thursday, November 7, 2024 - 18:18

I prefer ulysses, it's simpler and I don't consider £40 a year much for an app I use so much. They are also very good on support.

Down side, no windows version though I hear scrivener's windows version isn't great for accessibility, or wasn't, that may have changed.

I think scrivener is good, it's just a bit overblown and laborious for my work flow. I got ulysses support to set me up a template I liked so, when I'm done, just highlight and export to a perfectly formatted word file, no fuss.

I'd suggest trying both if you can to see which suits your needs better.